I love Chuck Liddell. Despite my adoration for technical nuance or prestige fighters, the charm of The Iceman has always loomed large in my fandom. Chuck Liddell is one of the most iconic fighters in MMA History, being inseparable from the UFC’s rise to prominence as arguably its strongest face as it became a household name in combat sports. With massive knockouts and a unique look that endures in memory to this day, Chuck Liddell’s place in history is solidified, and yet, unlike the greats of eras past, there is maybe nobody ever that is quite as dated as Chuck Liddell. His awkward stance, his 2006 aesthetic, his archaic appeal, he rooted in his time and place in history so much so that evaluating him as an all time great Light Heavyweight is nearly impossible. Separating the figure from the fighter is important for everybody of course, but for Liddell, it’s actually a pretty daunting task - So, let’s partake in the journey. Let’s Answer The Question of How Good Chuck Liddell was.
The first thing to understand about Liddell’s history is his era, which is potentially one of the most jam packed in history. Chuck Liddell’s breakout took place pretty unquestionably in 2001 - He entered the year 6-1, 3-1 in the UFC with a lone loss to Jeremy Horn, who even then was an esteemed journeyman. Liddell was a young, hard charging fighter in the UFC’s burgeoning Light Heavyweight division, matched up across from former UFC Heavyweight Champion Kevin Randleman just 1 fight removed from losing the title to Randy Couture. Randleman was crazy athletic, he was an explosive athlete and was used to controlling bigger, stronger opponents, so his move to Light Heavyweight was, almost certainly, to be a career rebound. Liddell would knock Randleman out in just over a minute. If that fight didn’t put Liddell on the map as a real contender, his next fight would be; just a few weeks later, Liddell went to Japan and fought Guy Mezger, a legacy Pancrase veteran with a rotten streak of luck after crossing over to PRIDE. Mezger was one of the most advanced fighters of his time, and his fight with Liddell is a slept on classic fight; the two laid hell on one another, including probably the hardest punch to ever land on a fighter that didn’t knock them out from Mezger that Liddell ate and just kept on pushing, eventually getting the knockout victory in the 2nd round. May 2001 put Liddell on the map as not only one of the heaviest handed Light Heavyweights in the world but also one who was incredibly durable and willing to engage with any level of opponent. Liddell’s run to become one of the best Light Heavyweights in the world would continue in 2002, when he beat Vitor Belfort and Renato “Babalu” Sobral, extended his win streak over the last 2 years to 6-0 with 3 knockouts. In 2002, Liddell has a claim for being the best Light Heavyweight in the world, but crowning him rank 1 would be… difficult.
The biggest issue with Liddell’s placement in history at this time are his contemporaries. In 2001, there were 4 fighters of prominence in what can loosely be called the Light Heavyweight Division; Tito Ortiz, the UFC Champion, Wanderlei Silva, the PRIDE Champion, Kazushi Sakuraba, one of the top pound for pound fighters in the world, and Dan Henderson, an openweight phenom making his name in Japan. The complicated nature of this division comes primarily in its classification; The UFC had a defined Light Heavyweight division dating back to 1997, with Tito Ortiz winning the vacant championship after the retirement of Frank Shamrock since 2000, but in Japan, the rigid lines that separated these divisions are a lot more blurry. In 2000, Kazushi Sakuraba ascended to the rank of best fighter in the world while Wanderlei Silva would knock out Guy Mezger and Dan Henderson, fighters who, when they competed in the UFC, would compete under the heavyweight division, but when they fought in Japan, were in this nebulous open weight class. For Liddell in 2002, his place in the UFC made his ranking pretty easy - he was underneath Tito Ortiz, the UFC’s most dominant champion, but how do you compare him with fighters across the ocean in PRIDE? It would depend on how you classed them. If you consider Wanderlei, Sakuraba and Dan Henderson to be Light Heavyweight fighters through 2000 and 2001, then the conversation of Wanderlei and Tito as the top Light Heavyweight in the world is an interesting one as Sakuraba was the #1 Pound for Pound fighter when Wanderlei beat him, but Tito has had a dominant title run and also the head to head vs Wanderlei. If you only classify them as Light Heavyweights from PRIDE 17 onward, as PRIDE 17 is when the company introduced divisional championships and, thus, forming a division, then the rankings at the end of 2002 look something like Tito Ortiz #1, Wanderlei Silva still #2, Chuck Liddell #3, Ricardo Arona #4 and someone else at #5, I don’t know. It’s an interesting conversation, and Chuck Liddell was in a fortuitous place at this point in time as he was in the same division as the #1 ranked Light Heavyweight and, based on conventional knowledge of the time period, had all the skills to beat him. Famously, the history was that Tito Ortiz held the title and had some kind of loose friendship or partnership with Chuck Liddell, and Liddell would take hard fights like Vitor and Babalu while Tito defended the championship, but refused to fight Liddell. Regardless, the eventual meeting between Tito Ortiz and Chuck Liddell would have to come eventually, and, it would… only, it would be a little less prestigious.
2003 is the year the Light Heavyweight division broke into being the epicenter of the sport, and there are two events that are responsible - the PRIDE Middleweight Grand Prix and Randy Couture. Let’s start witht he latter - Randy Couture was the best UFC Heavyweight there had ever been, winning the championship twice without ever having lost it, but in 2002, Couture would lose the title to Josh Barnett and lose again to Ricco Rodriguez, effectively signaling that his time was up, so he would attempt to extend his career by moving down to Light Heavyweight as Kevin Randleman had when Couture took the title from him. Like Randleman, Couture would be matched up against Chuck Liddell, potentially the best counter wrestler in MMA at the time who hit a whole lot harder than Ricco Rodriguez and Josh Barnett. Despite this danger, Randy Couture would absolutely hammer Chuck Liddell - the fight was never close, Liddell got walked down and beaten up on the feet by the older fighter, and when it came to the wrestling, Liddell got handed his ass for evne thinking of contending with one of the greats. It was a performance that shattered the win streak Liddell had built up, but also some of the mystique he’d built up as an unshakeable, undeniable power punching demigod. What’s worse, Couture would continue this momentum into a fight with Tito Ortiz, and would embarrass him as well, dominating him en route to becoming the UFC Light Heavyweight Champion. Conveniently enough, this shake up int he conversation for top Light Heavyweight and Chuck Liddell plays directly into the other major event in the 2003 Light Heavyweight division, the PRIDE Middleweight Grand Prix. Wanderlei Silva, Kazushi Sakuraba, Kiyoshi Tamura, Rampage Jackson, Murilo Bustamante, Alistair Overeem, a collection of elite talent young and old gathered in Japan to crown the best light heavyweight in the world, and even the UFC would heed the call. While Randy Couture and Tito Ortiz were set to fight and couldn’t commit to a placement in the Grand Prix, the UFC could loan out their now deposed contender with PRIDE Experience in Chuck Liddell to complete the 8 man field. In round 1, Liddell would have a hell of a fight against a young Alistair Overeem, but would overwhelm the young man 3 minutes into the first round, advancing to Final Conflict where he would meet Quinton “Rampage” Jackson. Rampage was kind of like an elseworld Liddell in a way, he was the young and explosive newcomer to the scene and would break into relevance by beating Kevin Randleman, but while Liddell worked with his hands, Rampage was much more proficient with his flashy slams and punishing ground and pound. If you’ve never seen Final Conflict 2003, it’s one of the most enduring events in history for a reason. First, it packed a record crowd of over 67,000 into the Tokyo Dome, a building with a capacity for 55,000. Second, the art of Chuck Liddell vs Rampage Jackson has to be seen to be believed. It’s kind of bizarre seeing a young Dana White, bad hairline and all, on commentary talking about Liddell’s chances vs Rampage and hyping an eventual Wanderlei Silva meeting, but it doesn’t get special until the fight ensues, and Rampage is bludgeoning Chuck Liddell with heavy hand after heavy hand, and Dana White, worryingly, insists that Chuck isn’t following the gameplan and that Liddell needs to follow the gameplan that they worked on. The isolation of Dana White in this moment has to be paralyzing, because he can’t just sulk in a corner, they have him on commentary to see Chuck Liddell, who was the UFC’s promising star just a year prior, get demolished by someone who is, at best, the 2nd best Light Heavyweight in PRIDE, something that was cemented in the Grand Prix finals when Wanderlei Silva cleaned Rampage out. The conversation at the end of 2003 for Best Light Heavyweight becomes a lot more interesting; Tito Ortiz held the #1 rank in 2002 not because his resume was better than Wanderlei’s, but because of his head to head victory and string of title defenses, but as Tito loses and Randy Couture supplants him as UFC’s best, that head to head over Wanderlei goes away. Wanderlei wins the PRIDE Grand Prix, knocking out Rampage in the finals, which, to me, solidifies Wanderlei as the best Light Heavyweight on the planet. Chuck Liddell, come 2003, sinks from 3rd rank to MAYBE #5, with Rampage and Tito Ortiz still being ahead of him. Liddell’s 2003 was his biggest low of his career at this point, he seemed to have been exposed as someone who could only beat fragile grapplers, but it would be the last low Liddell would see for a long time.
2004 int he UFC Light Heavyweight division was a bit of a mess. While Wanderlei Silva cemented his status as #1 in the world with his knockout of Rampage Jackson in a famous rematch of their Grand Prix finals bout, Randy Couture would waffle the UFC title back and forth with Vitor Belfort, losing the title by injury seconds into the first round of their fight but rebounding to win the rematch by TKO, leaving the status of the championship in the UFC in a weird place. For Chuck Liddell, he would knock out Pancrase veteran Vernon White and finally be matched up with Tito Ortiz, winning the fight by second round TKO to ascend to the #1 contender for the UFC Championship, ending the year ranked #4 behind Wanderlei, Couture and Rampage. Liddell’s career trajectory was trending upwards, but he would find himself across from Randy Couture in 2005, the man who emasculated him in an upset 2 years prior to become a top contender at his expense with a proclivity for embarrassing young, strong fighters. The rematch, however, would go very differently, with Liddell constantly circling to avoid Couture’s attempts to pressure him into the cage, taking an angle and knocking Couture dead with a hammer of a right hand, obtaining the UFC Championship after a 4 year chase and conquering his contemporaries. It was an incredible moment for Liddell, and after avenging his first loss in his first title defense against Jeremy Horn, the conversation could begin to be had about Chuck Liddell being the best Light Heavyweight int he world… the problem is that it could never hold weight because of the storm that was happening in Japan.
The 2005 PRIDE Middleweight Grand Prix was, and remains to be, the greatest collection of talent in an MMA Tournament in history. Some might say the Strikeforce Heavyweight Grand Prix, Real Ones might say the 2008 Dream Lightweight Grand Prix, galaxy brained coomers would counter with the 1994 King of Pancrase Tournament, but the 16 man field for the 2005 Pride Middleweight Grand Prix is absolutely unreal even without a UFC participant like they had in 2003. This tournament would be marked by several excellent runs; Wanderlei Silva’s rematch against Hidehiko Yoshida and great bout with Kazuhiro Nakamura, Ricardo Arona’s terrorist run to the finals wher ehe transformed Sakuraba’s face at Critical Countdown, Little Nog submitting Dan Henderson and having the fight of the year in his second round fight, but nobody comes close to the force of one Mauricio “Shogun” Rua. Shogun had debuted in PRIDE in 2004, fighting good not great opponents Akihiro Gono, Hiromitsu Kanehara and Akira Shoji, and the only thing that was known about Shogun was that he was violent. Hailing from the famous Chute Boxe Academy, the home of PRIDE Champion Wanderlei Silva, Shogun would be matched up across from #2 PRIDE Light Heavyweight Rampage Jackson, which represented both a fight from Ramapge against another Chute Boxe prodigy, but a family grudge match; Rampage faced Shogun’s brother, PRIDE veteran Murilo “Ninja” rua, earlier in the year, escaping via narrow and controversial split decision. Being matched up across from the less proven and less tenured younger brother of Ninja, as well as it being a Grand Prix, Rampage was expected to turn it up to 11 and teach young Shogun the way of things… Shogun put him through a blender. An absolutely horrific display of knees, punches and soccer kicks was Rampage’s fate at Total Elimination, losing by knockout in under 5 minutes to be eliminated from the tournament. Shogun just kept going, facing Little Nog at Critical Countdown in what many consider to be the fight of the year, winning a tight decision and entering Final Conflict to face a surging Alistair Overeem while Ricardo Arona faced PRIDE Champion Wanderlei Silva. Shogun would TKO Overeem in a hard fought battle, but on the other side of the bracket, something went wrong. Before the tournament, Wanderlei and Shogun made it clear they would not fight one another, planning to enter the finals and give the grand prix win to the Chute Boxe Academy, stamping their supremacy in eternity, and while Shogun would make it on his side, Wanderlei Silva, the best Light Heavyweight on hte planet and the reigning PRIDE Champion, would lose by upset decision to Ricardo Arona, setting up a Shogun vs Arona finals. There are all sorts of stories to tell about this bout, the history of Brazilian Top Team vs Chute Boxe, the career trajectory of Ricardo Arona, the gravity of this bout on this night, but the truth is that it would take longer than the fight lasts to explain it. Shogun’s fight with Arona is legendary - Arona gets a takedown and Shogun quickly starts to work for an Omoplata, using the position to sweep Arona and return to his feet. Content to play guard, Arona remains on his back, but Shogun jumps into the fire with a long stomp, clipping Arona and stunning him, and a few hammerfist strikes later, Shogun Rua is crowned the Middleweight Grand Prix Champion and the best Light Heavyweight on the planet. It was potentially the greatest year ever had by a fighter in MMA History, beating two top 5 fighters by knockout with the fight of the year to boot, which leaves Chuck Liddell in a weird space. Despite becoming UFC Champion and conquering his demons, Ricardo Arona and Shogun Rua skyrocket into the top of the division. Wanderlei Silva would rebound on New Years Eve, beating Arona in a close fought rematch to remain in hte top 3, which leaves Liddell on the outside looking in as the UFC’s best; it’s one of the worst draws of luck of all time - Liddell shored up, avenged his losses to Couture and Horn and knocked out Tito, but Shogun and Arona taking their birthright in Japan at the same time overshadows that, and with the doomsday clock ticking towards the end of Liddell’s top fighter run, the only chance he would have to claim the #1 spot would be 2006, the great divide in the Light Heavyweight division.
I use The Great Divide to define the sundering of Light Heavyweight Division’s peak eras. Pre and Post 2006, the Light Heavyweight division is a burgeoning division with contenders and storylines and drama to follow, but 2006 is an incredibly strange year for the glamor division of the sport. At the start of the year, the incumbent best Light Heavyweight Shogun fought aging heavyweight Mark Coleman, and had his arm broken during a takedown attempt that would keep him out for much of the year. Wanderlei Silva wouldn’t fight at Light Heavyweight at all, replacing PRIDE Heavyweight Champion Fedor Emelianenko in the 2006 Openweight Grand Prix, beating Kazuyuki Fujita but famously being demolished by Mirko Cro Cop. Ricardo Arona, after a breakout year, only fought once, beating Alistair Overeem. Rampage Jackson, after clearly being relegated to 3rd in the PRIDE division at best, fought only once in the company against Dong Sik Yoon, leaving to join a regional american company and fighting Matt Lindland. The division’s prestige fighters in Japan were almost entirely inactive for the body of the year… and then there was Chuck Liddell. 2006 is Chuck Liddell’s window to become the best Light Heavyweight in the world, with Shogun, Wanderlei, Arona and Rampage out of the picture, Liddell had the chance to seize public perception, and he would go for gold with knockout after knockout. Liddell would rematch Randy Couture, Babalu and Tito Ortiz, knocking out each of them before the second round ended, finishing the year with 4 total title defenses, settling his trilogy with Randy Couture, going 2-0 on Tito Ortiz and Babalu and avenging his Jeremy Horn loss. If ever there was a year you could say Chuck Liddell ended it as the #1 Light Heavyweight, or was ever the champion at any point in time, it would absolutely be in his remarkable 2006. Speaking personally, it’s a really tough call; while Shogun was injured in February, he did fight 3 more times in 2006, beating Cyrille Diabate, Kevin Randleman and Kazuhiro Nakamura, all solid fighters, but none of them remarkable like Tito Ortiz and Randy Couture. The question really comes in timing and distance; Couture’s 2005 saw him end ranked 4th behind Shogun, Wanderlei and Arona, so it can be surmised that the distance between Liddell and Shogun was a pretty dramatic gulf. From the start of the year until Shogun returned in September, Chuck Liddell had the opportunity to not only close that gap, but perhaps sneak into #1 as Wanderlei, Rampage and Arona weren’t active to steal it in the first place. The problem is that Liddell followed a pretty similar trajectory; he would fight Couture in February and Babalu in August, sneaking in the weakest of his 3 wins in the non Shogun window. While Couture, Babalu and Ortiz victories are better than Shogun’s year, to me, the gulf between liddell and shogun was just too large - Liddell succeeded in fighting his way to #2 in the world, meaning that the UFC championship was technically superior than PRIDE’s for the first time since 2003, but make no mistake, the best Light Heavyweight in the world was still Mauricio “Shogun” Rua, and unfortunately for Liddell, the Deathclock was about to strike midnight.
Nobody can fight forever; Chuck Liddell being a top 5, sometimes top 3, Light Heavyweight from 2001 to 2006 is incredibly impressive, but on the other side of the great divide was the cold bite of reality. 2007 was the ultimate Paradigm shift at Light Heavyweight; in one fell swoop, the top 4 Light Heavyweights, Shogun, Liddell, Wanderlei and Arona, would lose one after another. The first was Wanderlei Silva, who would fall to a familiar face of the past in Dan Henderson at PRIDE 33, losing the PRIDE Light Heavyweight Championship he had carried since its inception. The next was Ricardo Arona, the ever consistent rock of Japan. Arona had sunk in activity, but would compete at PRIDE’s swan song at PRIDE 34 against Rameau Thierry Sokoudjou, a cameroonian fighter who broke into PRIDE at PRIDE 33, knocking out Little Nog in 20 seconds in one of the most shocking upsets in MMA History. Arona and Sokoudjou fought, and once again, Sokoudjou performed a historic upset, knocking out Ricardo Arona in under 2 minutes, cementing himself as potentially the most scary Light Heavyweight in the world. The next to fall was Chuck Liddell, who had the chance to avenge the final unaccounted for loss in his career when he faced Quinton “Rampage” Jackson, who had stagnated tremendously since 2004. When Rampage met Liddell, Liddell didn’t get pounded into the middle of the canvas as he did in 03, instead Rampage caught him with a Right Hook as he exited and slept the titan of the UFC’s 2000’s. Finally, the last to fall - the best of them all, Mauricio “Shogun” Rua. Shogun entered the UFC to face symbolic hero Forrest Griffin, a solid mid card fighter who had been the winner of the UFC’s salvation, The Ultimate Fighter reality show. Nobody could predict that TUF would save the UFC, but with Chuck Liddell and Randy Couture as coaches, Forrest Griffin would win the inaugural season and go onto a pretty middling career in the UFC, seeming like he was just one step away from the elite as he faces Tito Ortiz, only to fight journeyman Keith Jardine and get knocked out in the first round. Shogun entered a massive favorite to destroy Forrest Griffin and fight for the title against incumbent champion Rampage Jackson in a rematch from 2005, but Griffin would shock the world by submitting Shogun, who looked a shell of his former self. The Great Divide separated the different eras of the light heavyweight division, and if that’s the case, 2007 was the purging of the old. Chuck Liddell, in an instant, was swept away along with all of the greats from Japan, and since he was the 3rd to lose, he never even had that window to be ranked above Shogun before his time came.
There are many legends of the sport who never ascended to being a pound for pound great or even the best fighter in their weight class. The fate of many of these fighters is typically to be washed away by the passage of time, circumstance clearly not being on their side, but Chuck Liddell isn’t that. Chuck Liddell is a beloved icon of the beginning of what would be called the modern UFC, continuing momentum built by Tito Ortiz as a pay per view attraction and levying that into helping The Ultimate Fighter break into popularity, which resulted in the saving of the company. Liddell was, like Tito Ortiz or Wanderlei Silva, a product of his time, but the time he was a defining feature of was when much of the future was being molded. Liddell’s championship reign is one of the best ever, and while he’s not a transcendent fighter who’s skillset can be lauded or his win list can be deified, he is one of the greatest fighters in a division who’s history is potentially the richest in the sport. For me, Chuck Liddell was never the best fighter at Light Heavyweight, nor was he ever worthy of being ranked #1, but on a list of all time great Light Heavyweights? I’d be comfortable hanging Liddell at #5, behind Jones, Shogun, Wanderlei and Rampage. That sounds… good to me.
Comments
Post a Comment